HRzone blogs

Editor's blog live: CIPD 2009 - A new leadership paradigm?

Back to blog homepage for: Charlie Duff: Editor's Blog

The third day of the conference was one which asked more questions than delivered answers.

On the last day of the annual conference, there was a certain amount of questioning of the HR function, and what the future is: Sharon Doherty, Group HR and Organisational Effectiveness Director for Laing O’Rouke, in her ‘Beyond business partnering’ speech, asked the audience how many of their CEOs felt HR is truly aligned with the business. The response was perhaps a little shy – in itself a sign that HR is still not confident with this strategic role which is deemed essential to the business and the future of HR.

The continual self-reflecting and questioning sounds useful- questioning the status quo is usually a good thing - but for HR it has become damaging. The continual soul searching only serves to feed the whiny image which is not helping HR recruit the best and brightest - particularly from the graduates and MBAs the industry badly needs.

Sharon pointed out that you would never find a finance department questioning itself to this extent. Why should HR feel at pains to continually justify itself? It's a good question.

Sharon then gave the assembled HR practicioners a choice. Three options for the future of HR:
1/ HR gets muscled out - presumably back into the admin role it has fought so hard to lose
2/ HR remains the same - status quo reigns
3/ We stop trying to justify ourselves, transform the role into an essential lever for growth and potential.

Where do you see HR in ten years time?

Be honest now...

The audience voted overwhemingly for the third option. Inspired by Jim Collins and having all read the Rough Guide to Happiness the night before, there's no stopping this year's delegates. The question which remains is how this will happen - what will you do in your organisation to achieve it?

The third keynote was presided over by John Humphrys: his dulcet tones organising, questioning and puzzling the candidates in turn, making a lively discussion.

Christopher Kelly began the panel discussion by stressing the importance of values in leadership. He illustrated this with the MP expenses scandal, citing this as an obvious and very public failure of leadership.

Steve Easterbrook, who pointed out he worked on McDonald's HR 'five days a week' (who could he be referring to, the assembled collectively wondered...) made a good point about values too, and about sticking to your organisational values no matter what. Leadership needs to be sustainable and the senior team must be fully engaged and integrated with all levels of the organisation.

Shaa Wasmund, widely toted as the voice of the under-30's and the 'twitter' generation, she put across some very good points, including the need for ethical leadership (harking back to Jim Collins saying 'pick leaders who are ambitious, but not for themselves')instant access to information, the openess giving a need to be honest and ethical. She cited ancient democracy, with her fear than too much power in the hands of too few, is dangerous. Today's world means we are all leaders - leaders of few, leaders of many, leaders of thought... leaders without title.

John pressed the panel for a definition of what was actually new about the 'new leadership paradigm'when leadership has always needed to be more honest and ethical.

Steve Easterbrook had to agree - indeed, corrruption and the fear of too much power in the hands of too few was what inspired radical democracy in the first place. However it remains a constant strggle and John's comment of 'in the old days' gave creedance to the fact that things have and are changing, not least in the sphere of social media, which as readers could see, the conference spawned well over a thousand tweets, many including links, blogs, photos, articles and thoughts from people both inside and outside the conference. Information is getting heard: everything is more open to scrutiny.

Shaa added that past leaders were in it for themselves: leaders who lead authentically lead with passion and sincerity.

What does leadership mean to you? Are we entering a new paradigm?

And then: if we know where we want to go, how do we get there?

Create your free account

  • Access all articles in full
  • View multimedia
  • Receive email bulletins
  • Private messaging
Register now

Login

Forgotten your password?

Editor's Welcome

 

Hello! And welcome back as we enter 2012, with a busy year ahead of us all. With talk of double-dip recessions, a possible partial or even full break-up of the Eurozone and unemployment rates set to hit nearly 9%, topics such as organisational streamlining, staff resilience and talent management are likely to be on many an HR professional's lips over the next 12 months.
 
But to lighten the gloom here in the UK, we also have the Queen's Diamond Jubilee and its attendant public holidays to look forward to at the start of June. Followed by two weeks of Olympic Games from 27 July to 12 August and the Paralympics from 29 August to 9 September, each generating their own excitement, but also issues to work through for hard-pressed HR departments trying to sort out the multifarious staffing issues in advance.
 
So with an interesting but challenging year to come, HRZone promises to be with you, supporting you all the way and providing our usual insightful blend of news, analysis, community blogs and expert comment to help you sort the wheat from the chaff. As ever, we love to hear from you too so feel free to either post your words of wisdom to our blog section yourself or, in the case of longer, more in-depth ‘expert voice’ articles, drop me a line with any ideas to cath.everett@siftmedia.co.uk.....
 
Cath Everett
HRZone Editor 
 
 
Here's our pick of some of the latest hot topics on the site:
 

HR Yearbook 2011

HR Heath and wellbeing